We all encounter dilemmas or deadlock
situations in our day-to-day life. Doing the right thing under all situations
is essential to being a responsible individual. But this 'Doing
the Right thing' is very subjective and with reference to a natural state. Under Same situations, different people, act differently. For a sage, doing the
right thing could be helping the needy; but for a terrorist, it could be to
destruct the life of people. Our decisions are dominated by the influence from
emotional and intelligent quotients based on our perceived experiences, be it
personal or gathered from other sources. Similarly, beyond individuals,
institutions, governments, communities, military, industry, economy etc. all
entities have their own way of doing the right thing. In order to establish a
peaceful world, it becomes necessary to have harmony between
socio-economic-natural phenomena. Then defining what as 'Doing the right thing'
that drives the system to its natural state of equilibrium becomes important. I would like to share with you some thoughts from Vedic Literature to contemplate.
In the Vedic literature, you might have
come across two words 'Dharma' and ‘AachAra’.
‘Dharma’ is an overloaded word for the natural
state of a system or an entity. ‘AachAra’ is an overloaded word for the concept of doing the right
thing in a given situation at a given time by an entity. An entity could be an individual, a place, time, living/non-living thing,
government, relationship, process, policy, occupation, various systems etc. Doing
the right thing (‘AachAra’) helps in being in the natural state of a system (‘Dharma’).
This concept of 'Dharma' and ‘AachAra’ finds its place explicitly in most of
the oriental texts. However, implicitly it applies to everything in
this universe and hence it is a universal concept rather than a religious idea.
This is indeed the spirit of Vedic Civilization, that their views are not in
favour of any person or a group of individuals but upholding the principles of totality (PoorNatvam), universality (sarvatvam) and eternity (Sanatanatvam).
If basis for Achara (Doing the right thing) is Dharma, Then, what is the basis of 'Dharma'?
Infinite repository of eternal Knowledge
(Vedas) forms the first and foremost basis for 'Dharma'. The rationale for
Vedas being the first hand source are:
a) Vedas have witnessed the universe much more than man. Because Knowledge existed in the first place, it was the man who could realized it later.
b) Tenets of the Collective repository of infinite universal knowledge of the absolute truth is handed down from generations to generations with due diligence adhering to the strict principles of spiritual practice.
a) Vedas have witnessed the universe much more than man. Because Knowledge existed in the first place, it was the man who could realized it later.
b) Tenets of the Collective repository of infinite universal knowledge of the absolute truth is handed down from generations to generations with due diligence adhering to the strict principles of spiritual practice.
If one does not find an answer in Vedas,
the next basis is 'Smruthis'. 'Smruthi' means memory. These are born out of
understanding and realising the Vedas by Rishis of great reputation. Manu,
Yajnavalkya, Parashara etc. Although, Manu Smruthi has been criticized heavily
in the 20th century for
various social and political reasons, We need an unbiased holistic study on it.
Kalidasa, the famous poet of Sanskrit literature opines, “If these Smruthis
were to be merely authored by a person, then there is an option to reject it.
But Smruthis are the realization of the absolute truth and therefore cannot be
simply ignored”. Hence Smruthis of Personalities of highest reputation form the
second basis for 'Dharma'.
These intellectual personalities (Sages)
have highest personality traits that are difficult to pursue and maintain it
under control at all times such as being ego-less, being emotionally kind and
tender like a flower yet being intellectually strong like a diamond, perform
self-less actions for the betterment of the world while enjoying the eternal
bliss. If one does not find answer to what is 'Dharma' in Vedas and 'Smruthis',
the next resort is the ‘AachAra’ - actions of such personalities under similar
or dissimilar situations. Their exemplary life itself becomes the third basis towards
‘Dharma’. Follow the leader when you are clueless !
If one does not find answer for 'What is
the right thing' even in the exemplary life of personalities, then the last
resort for ‘Dharma’ is one’s own Conscience! Follow what your heart says !
Some people might argue about going in the
reverse order to seek basis for 'Dharma' by 'Doing the Right Thing' by saying I will only follow my self-Conscience, then if needed watch for actions by
great personalities who have led an exemplary life, and then look at Scriptures and finally seek advice from established Philosophies. This might seem reasonable if we are egocentric. But soon, this
argument fades away if one examines carefully and realizes that an ordinary individual's experiences
are limited when compared to an exemplary life of a great personality. A life
of great personality seems limited when compared to the realization of the eternal knowledge. Realization itself seems to be limited when compared to the
absolute-infinite-eternal Knowledge (Vedas) that encompasses the entire
universe. Thereby forming the Basis for 'Dharma' and its associated 'Action'.
Let me stop here and leave you with some food for thought on
the concept of ‘Dharma’ and its connection to quest for 'Doing the Right Thing'!
The post looks bit abstract. There looks to be scope for some examples and, putting it in layman terms. Otherwise, a nice topic that you have covered.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your feedback! I will try to make it simpler and easy to read in the future.
Delete